See the article’s sources and scope. Our editorial standards
The choice in practical terms
Start with the BRZ if a fixed roof, a folding rear seat and carrying flexibility are requirements. Start with the NC if open-top driving is the attraction and a two-seat layout works for your routine. Those packaging differences can settle the shortlist before you compare asking prices.
Our reference cars are a 2015 US Subaru BRZ Premium six-speed manual and a 2015 US Mazda MX-5 Miata Sport soft-top five-speed manual. The same year keeps the document comparison explicit. It does not make every BRZ or NC equivalent to these examples. Gearline researched the specifications; we did not drive either car.
What the specifications actually say
| Measure | BRZ Premium 6MT | MX-5 Sport soft top 5MT |
|---|---|---|
| Engine layout | 2.0-liter flat-four | 2.0-liter inline-four |
| Published engine output | 200 hp | 167 hp |
| Published torque | 151 lb-ft | 140 lb-ft |
| Driven wheels | Rear | Rear |
| Seating capacity | 4 | 2 |
| Roof | Fixed coupe roof | Manual soft top |
| Base curb mass | 2,764 lb | 2,480 lb, federal specification |
| Overall length | 166.7 in | 157.3 in, with license-plate holder |
| Body width | 69.9 in, excluding mirrors | 67.7 in, published width |
| Wheelbase | 101.2 in | 91.7 in |
| Published trunk volume | 6.9 cu ft | 5.3 cu ft |
| Original tire size | 215/45R17 | 205/50R16 |
Subaru's product sheet, distributed by Subaru of New England, supplies the BRZ figures; its equipment sheet identifies the roof and folding rear seat. Mazda's US specification deck supplies the NC figures on its final specifications page (PDF page 12). These are new-car specifications, not measurements of a used example.
Space: what to try at the viewing
The BRZ is 9.4 inches longer using the listed dimensions, and its stated trunk volume is 1.6 cubic feet greater. These are useful screening differences, but neither proves that your suitcase fits through the opening. Bring your normal bags and try them in each car.
The BRZ's rear seat adds an option absent from the two-seat Mazda. Subaru lists 29.9 inches of rear legroom: do not turn seating capacity into a promise of comfortable adult travel. Set the front seat for the driver first and have the intended passenger assess the remaining space. Secure the load when using the seat folded.
For the NC, try your bags with the roof in the position you will actually use. The power-retractable-hardtop version is a separate configuration, not the Sport soft top in this table. Check its own equipment and weight rather than combining the hard roof with the lighter model's numbers.
Power and weight: show both sides
The BRZ has 33 more rated horsepower; the selected Mazda is 284 lb lighter. Weight per horsepower is 2,764 / 200 = 13.82 lb/hp for the BRZ and 2,480 / 167 = 14.85 lb/hp for the Mazda. Lower is better for this ratio.
Expressed as horsepower per 1,000 lb, the results are 72.36 and 67.34. The BRZ's power per unit of mass is about 7.46% higher on these inputs. That is a calculated comparison, not a measured acceleration advantage. Gearing, traction, tires, driver, actual mass and installed equipment are outside the calculation.
Use the power-to-weight calculator to reproduce it. Keep engine output with engine output; a wheel-dyno number for one car would change the basis. Modified cars need their own documented inputs.
Trim and transmission change the answer
Mazda's Sport manual has five speeds; its Club and Grand Touring manuals have six. The Club manual also has different documented suspension and differential equipment. A seller mentioning “six-speed” or “Bilsteins” should prompt configuration checking, rather than an automatic increase in the price you consider reasonable.
An automatic NC has a different published power rating from the manual here, and the PRHT has separate weight entries. A BRZ Limited also differs from the Premium baseline. Write the actual trim, transmission, roof and modifications at the top of both listings before comparing numbers.
The original tire sizes differ. Get replacement quotes for the sizes actually fitted, including installation. Our tire-size comparison explains nominal geometry; it cannot establish that a wheel or tire is approved for either car.
Compare the first-year commitment
For each listing, separate asking price, transaction expenses, quoted initial work and an owner-chosen reserve. Keep undiagnosed leaks, roof concerns or warning lights as open questions instead of assigning a zero-dollar repair cost.
Use the NC inspection worksheet for roof and cooling evidence, or the combined BRZ buying guide for seller questions, recall scope and inspection findings. Those records help explain why two similar asking prices may represent different commitments.
Fuel requires another assumption. Enter your distance, consumption and local pump price into the fuel calculator; label brochure mileage as an estimate rather than measured consumption. Insurance, finance, parking and maintenance need separate quotes. The ownership budget guide keeps those categories distinct.
Leave with a decision you can explain
Download the BRZ and NC comparison sheet (CSV). It keeps the published baseline together and gives you blank fields for the actual cars, load fit, inspection, known expenses and unresolved questions. Edit a copy on your device; no entries are sent to Gearline.
Our recommendation is conditional: prioritize the BRZ when carrying flexibility and a permanent roof are requirements; prioritize the NC when open-top driving and the compact two-seat package are the reason for buying. If either fails a requirement you cannot compromise on, its horsepower ratio will not resolve that conflict. When both meet your needs, use the condition evidence and complete initial-work budget to break the tie.
Scope: the named 2015 US configurations and sources below, checked October 26, 2026. This is document research and editorial interpretation, not a road test, current market valuation or reliability ranking.
Sources and research
- Subaru 2015 BRZ product specifications, distributed by Subaru of New England (pages 1, 2, 4 and 6) · Checked 2026-10-26
- Subaru 2015 BRZ standard and optional equipment · Checked 2026-10-26
- Mazda 2015 US MX-5 specification deck (equipment chart and PDF page 12) · Checked 2026-10-26
Update: Updated October 26, 2026: expanded the named-configuration comparison with packaging, weight, tires, reproducible ratios and a downloadable decision sheet.



